When Helping Becomes Taking Over

I had a weird experience this past weekend. For the past 3 semesters, I’ve been going to universities to talk to audiences of young women about domestic violence and the difference between healthy and unhealthy relationships. Sometimes I am the only “adult” in the room, and sometimes advisors or university officials are there too, depending on the group.

This particular weekend, an older woman advisor was in the room. She introduced herself to me when I walked in and told me how grateful she was that I was there to lead the conversation on domestic violence, and we had a lovely chat about my experience and what I was hoping to have the women get out of the presentation today.

My presentation started as usual; I introduced myself, set the expectations for the afternoon, and issued my trigger and content warnings. I explained upfront that we are going to talk about domestic violence and that we are going to watch a film together (Escalation by the One Love Foundation) that shows, in detail, the start of an abusive relationship all the way through the eventual killing of one partner by the other. I explain that I want the individuals to take care of themselves, step out of the room if they need to, use their coping skills, and to not tough it out. 

I expect people to step out of the room if they need to, and this weekend was no exception. A few women left the room and did not rejoin until after the break. 

After the break, we talk about healthy relationships, boundaries, and how to intervene if you know someone is potentially in an abusive relationship. The rest of the training went as usual. 

The advisor came up to me after the session and discussed her concerns about the young women who had left the room. She wanted to make me aware that she had spent some time talking with them and trying to comfort them. She had expressed her discomfort with what happens if I am the only “adult” and no one is there to comfort those young women, and suggested that I front-load more coping skills and potentially not show the film anymore because it was too triggering for people.

I found myself thinking about that conversation long after I left. Not because I disagreed that the material was difficult, or because I didn't appreciate her concern for the young women. I actually think her concern was genuine. But I kept coming back to a question: At what point does our desire to protect someone from discomfort become more about our own discomfort than theirs?

When I was doing my EMDR (eye movement desensitization and reprocessing) training, there was a lot of focus on owning your own discomfort as the clinician during a session. So often, a reprocessing session stops not because the client is unable to continue processing, but because the clinician becomes uncomfortable and needs to stop. That discomfort can get in the way of the healing the client needs to achieve.

I understand that. I really do. It can be incredibly uncomfortable to hear about the deepest, darkest wounds someone might be carrying. I've sat in the therapist's chair and felt deeply uncomfortable hearing about the things that have happened to my clients. I've told clients before that I can handle most things they bring into the room, but I will always struggle with stories of animal abuse. Not because I don't want them to process those experiences, but because I might cry while they do. I don’t let my emotional reaction take away from the processing they need to do, nor am I ever going to put them in a position where they feel responsible for taking care of me and my emotions. But healthy brains are going to cry sometimes.

But what does that do to the client when we stop the processing for them? What lesson does it teach them?

It can teach the people that their problems are too big, too overwhelming, or too much for them to manage. It can reinforce the belief that they need someone else, particularly an adult or authority figure, to step in and manage things for them. It can contribute to learned helplessness and keep someone trapped in unhealthy power dynamics, where the underlying message becomes, "Someone else has to take care of me because I can't take care of myself."

I know the natural inclination, perhaps even the kind one, is to try to take someone's pain away. We see someone hurting, and we want to make that hurt stop. But in situations where the pain is part of the process, where we need to work through it in order to heal and grow from the things that have hurt us, taking that pain away can do more harm than good. We don't heal because we hurt; sometimes we have to be willing to experience the hurt as part of healing.

Of course, this shouldn't come at the expense of pushing ourselves beyond what we can tolerate. I want people to know their own limits and feel empowered to say, "This is more than I can handle right now." That's why I give content warnings, encourage people to step out and take care of themselves, and allow stop signals during EMDR processing. You know your limits far better than I do. The pain may be part of the process, but you get to decide how much of it you're ready and willing to experience.

Let's go back to that power dynamic I mentioned. Particularly when we're talking about healing from domestic violence or unhealthy relationships, stepping in to take someone's pain away can feel like an act of kindness. But it can also put you in a position where you become the person who takes the pain away, inadvertently making the victim reliant on you to manage their emotions and experiences. You're now the person with the power to make things better, and they're the person who needs you to do it. The helper can unintentionally reinforce some of the same underlying dynamics: someone else has the answers, someone else makes the decisions, someone else has the power to make things better.

I know. That wasn't your intent.

But it can look an awful lot like the relationship you’re potentially trying to help them leave. In an abusive relationship, someone else's power and control can erode a person's belief in their own ability to make decisions, manage their circumstances, and trust themselves. When a well-intentioned helper takes over, even for compassionate reasons, they risk reinforcing that same loss of agency.

I want to be clear about something. I don't think there's anything wrong with offering a compassionate ear. In fact, I'm glad that advisor was there to step out of the room, sit with those young women, and cry with them. I'm glad they had someone who was willing to be present with them in that moment.

But what I don't want is to change the presentation or change the way we talk about domestic violence and unhealthy relationships to avoid those uncomfortable moments. The people who are in those relationships need to understand how harmful they can be. People who aren't in those relationships need to know how to recognize them and, more importantly, how to help someone who might be experiencing one. Not by taking away their pain or trying to fix everything for them, but by being a compassionate listening ear, respecting their autonomy, and serving as a source of support and resources.

There is a responsibility to make these conversations safe, thoughtful, and trauma-informed. But trauma-informed doesn't mean trauma-avoidant. Sometimes the most compassionate thing we can do is give people the information they need, allow them to have their reactions, and trust them to decide what they need next.

So how do we actually help in situations like this? If I could offer advice to someone in the advisor's position, particularly someone who isn't a therapist, this is what I would say:

  • Sit with the discomfort without trying to take it away. You don't have to fix someone's feelings to be supportive. Sometimes being willing to sit beside someone while they're having a difficult experience is enough.

  • Offer resources without taking it personally if someone chooses not to use them. Your job is to make resources available, not to convince someone that they need them or make their decisions for them.

  • Follow their lead. Ask, "What would feel supportive right now? I can offer a few things, like sitting with you, helping you find resources, or just listening. What would be most helpful?"

  • Respect their decisions. Someone may not be ready to talk, accept help, or take the next step you think they should take. That doesn't mean you've failed them. It means their decisions belong to them.

We shouldn't make difficult conversations less difficult at the expense of the people who need to hear them. But we should make sure we're prepared to support those people in ways that are genuinely helpful, rather than unintentionally taking away the very agency we're trying to help them reclaim.

Next
Next

Good Enough Isn't Always Good Enough: What We're Giving Away When We Outsource Therapy